“The Most Disgusting, Disgraceful and Inequitous Proceeding in our Law’: The Action for Breach of Promise of Marriage in Nineteenth Century Ontario”

“The Most Disgusting, Disgraceful and Inequitous Proceeding in our Law’: The Action for Breach of Promise of Marriage in Nineteenth Century Ontario”

“The Most Disgusting, Disgraceful and Inequitous Proceeding in our Law’: The Action for Breach of Promise of Marriage in Nineteenth Century Ontario.” University of Toronto Law Journal 38: 64 – 108.

Abstract: This study examines judicial management of the action for breach of promise of marriage in nineteenth-century Ontario through an analysis of reported cases, trial records, and newspaper accounts. This seldom researched area of legal history sheds light on the interplay between cultural ideology and legal developments. Breach of promise of marriage cases elicited much societal attention and often consternation because they challenged widely held attitudes on women’s participation in the legal system. This study also illustrates how judges at the time exhibited a strong commitment to judicial autonomy in the face of contentious juridical gender issues, as these cases often threatened Victorian visions of social order.

Link to article

PDF


Date Published: 1988
Publisher: University of Toronto Law Journal
Publisher Website: https://www.utpjournals.press/loi/utlj